Once you get the hang of it, making overnight sourdough bread is a simple thing to add into your schedule…and it tastes delicious!
I love to make food the old fashioned way without lots of extra accessories. In this blog post, I’ll give you step-by-step instructions on how to make overnight sourdough bread without all the extras. I think you’ll fall in love with this simple sourdough bread – like grandma used to make! You won’t have to look for sourdough bread recipes ever again!
Sourdough bread is made the way people have made bread for thousands of years. It yields a chewy texture with a slightly tangy flavor, making it an absolutely delicious bread. It uses a sourdough starter that contains flour, water, and wild yeast from the air. The other ingredients are salt, flour, and water. That’s all!
Is overnight sourdough bread better for you?
A long fermentation sourdough bread gives time for the bacteria and yeast in the culture to go to work eating up the gluten and carbs in your flour. Because of this, many people who have sensitivities to gluten can often eat sourdough without issues. *This does not apply to people with true gluten allergies, like those with Celiac *
Sourdough also works to break down the phytic acid in the flour, making it more easily digestible. Additionally, my husband is diabetic, and when I bake things with sourdough and ferment them overnight like my sourdough pancakes or sourdough burger buns, they don’t affect his sugar as strongly!
Honestly, I think that using sourdough for baked goods is the easiest way to begin to change your eating habits without eating very differently!
Tools you’ll need for easy overnight sourdough bread
This post contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.
Because I try to use accessories you’ll already have on hand, I think there’s only 2 things you’ll need that you may not have. The first is a kitchen scale. They are really important when you’re baking in order to get consistent results. You can find an inexpensive one on Amazon that will serve you for a long time.
The other thing you’ll need is a cast iron dutch oven for baking the overnight sourdough bread. I’ve been experimenting with how to make sourdough without the dutch oven, but I haven’t gotten consistently good results yet. I’ll share them as soon as I do!
Other than those two items, you should have all the other tools – bowl, wooden spoon, plastic wrap, etc…around the house! So here’s the first and only sourdough recipe you’ll need!
Ingredients for Easy Overnight Sourdough Bread
Unbleached flour (all purpose or bread flour)
I usually use King Arthur flour because I know it is high in protein which allows the gluten structure to develop well. But I go back and forth between their bread flour and the all purpose flour. Both seem to work well.
No matter what brand you choose, just make sure it is not bleached, as that could also damage your yeast in the starter. A great way to see which variety of flour you like better is to bake a batch with all purpose flour and another with bread flour and see if you get different results.
I recommend using white flour for your first loaf of sourdough bread to give you the best and fluffiest results. The sourdough loaf using all white flour tends to turn out well without many issues. After you’ve got the hang of it, you can play around with the dough ingredients and replace about 30% of the overall weight of flour with whole wheat flour or rye flour or spelt flour. It adds a nutty and rich flavor to the bread. But, adding too much flour that is whole grain can tend to make the loaves very dense.
Filtered Water
It is important not to use tap water for this recipe. The chemicals and fluoride in the water can kill your active yeast culture. You’ll want to make sure you’re using some sort of filtered water for this recipe. I use this Aquasana filter under my sink for our filtered water.
Himalayan Sea Salt
I use Himalayan sea salt in my home because the minerals have not been stripped out of it. But any old salt would work fine!
Bubbly and active starter
I originally got sourdough starter from my brother in law. Over time, though, I learned how to make my own. It was so freeing to know that I had the skills to make it myself if I ever accidentally killed it – like I have done many times!
(Because I’ve killed it a few times, I now keep preserved sourdough starter on hand. You can read my blog post here on how to freeze sourdough starter. I have another blog post here on how to dry sourdough starter. )
When you buy sourdough in stores, they often add commercial yeast to make the bread rise quicker. Unfortunately, the long fermentation process is what gives the health benefits of sourdough bread. Making it yourself without commercial yeast and just your own starter full of wild yeast yields a better and healthier bread.
I put off making my own sourdough starter because I was terrified that I would ruin it. When I did it for the first time, I was shocked at how easy it was to mix a little flour and water and watch the wild yeast colonize! I wanted to make it even easier for you by making a Sourdough Starter Checklist that takes all the guesswork out of it. I’ve included instructions on one page, and a handy little checklist on the second page to help you remember where you are in the process. Fill out the information below to have your Easy Sourdough Starter Checklist sent to your email box!
Feeding the Sourdough Starter
Once you have a starter that is ready to use, you begin by feeding the starter to get it good and bubbly. I usually use 100g. of starter, 100g. of filtered water, and 100g. of unbleached flour. Mix it up and allow it to sit for 6-8 hours until it is doubled in size.
I normally do this around lunchtime so that a couple hours before bedtime it’s ready for me to mix up my dough.
It should look like this after it’s mixed up. It’s kind of like thick pancake batter. Put a lid on it but it doesn’t need to be screwed on tight. I just put it on and very gently screw it on.
Make sure you have it in a jar that is at least big enough for the starter to double. It always stinks to come back to sourdough starter drying all over your jar and countertop because your container was too small and it bubbled over! I usually use a quart mason jar for mine.
This one is starting to get bubbly in the picture below. It hasn’t doubled but it’s beginning to work. When it’s all bubbly and doubled in size, you can begin to make your overnight sourdough bread. Again, this normally takes 6-8 hours.
Mixing the Ingredients for Overnight Sourdough Bread
About 2 hours before bed, mix all the ingredients (flour, water, starter, and salt) in a large mixing bowl with a wooden spoon. I begin by mixing my water, salt and starter together with a danish whisk. You can absolutely use a wooden spoon. It works great too. I just love how the danish whisk works for this part!
I add the water first, and then put the sourdough starter on top of it. This allows the starter to float on top of the water, showing that it is ready to use because the bubbles in it allow it to pass the float test!
After you’ve mixed the starter, water and salt, go ahead and add the flour. I add it all at once and then begin to mix it all in.
Oftentimes you won’t be able to incorporate all the flour into the dough using a wooden spoon or a danish whisk. That’s totally fine! At this point, just use your hands to work the flour in. You don’t need to worry about kneading the dough. Just get to the point where all the dry bits of flour are mixed in. It will make a shaggy dough and that’s ok! As you work the dough through the sets of stretch and folds, it will become a smooth ball and it will come together beautifully.
Stretch and Folds
Now, cover the dough with plastic wrap. You’ll need to do 4 sets of stretch and folds in the two hours before you head to bed. Set the timer for a half hour. Once it goes off, do a set of stretch and folds and set the timer for a half hour again and do that until you have done it 4 times.
It does not have to be that scientific. If you’re less forgetful than I am, you can just wander over to it every half hour or so to do the stretches. It doesn’t technically have to be at 30 minute intervals. Just make sure you get 4 sets in before you go to bed.
Why do stretch and folds?
Doing stretch and folds in sourdough bread is equivalent to kneading regular bread dough. It works the dough to give it more structure and develop the gluten. Sourdough is a simple process, but not easy enough to mix it and forget it. You’ll want to make sure you do this series of folds in order to have a light and fluffy loaf.
Sometimes the first couple of sets of stretch and folds can be a little sticky, so it’s often helpful to have wet hands when you do them. Additionally, as you complete the stretch and folds, you’ll see that any little dry bits get integrated into the dough more completely.
How to perform stretch and folds
After it’s been sitting about 30 minutes, uncover the dough and complete a series of “stretch and folds”. You do this by grabbing the dough, stretching it up and folding it over. Turn the dough 1/4 turn and repeat.
Do this 4-8 times until the dough is too tight to stretch. Sometimes when it starts getting tight and won’t stretch easily, I’ll try to stretch it and then bounce the dough to get it to stretch enough for me to fold it over.
After you’ve done 4-8 stretch and pulls, cover the dough with plastic wrap. Repeat this process every 30 minutes for 2 hours, or a total of 4 times.
Bulk Rise
After the final stretch and fold, cover the dough with plastic wrap and allow it to sit for its first rise overnight. This is usually called the bulk rise or the bulk fermentation. I don’t get super fancy. My dough just rises overnight and usually when I wake up, it has doubled in size and is full of beautiful air bubbles. I’d guess it rises about 8-10 hours.
How ambient temperature affects rise time
I should probably mention that the room temperature controls how fast or slow your bread rises. The cooler it is, the slower it rises. Warmer kitchens will cause the dough to rise in less time, and may rise too much if you sleep for more than 8 hours. I had a batch this summer that was in my super hot house and rose really fast. It was fine and did not overproof, but it did make for a more sour bread!
One thing you’ll learn with sourdough is that there are no absolutes! If you have air conditioning and heat, then you’ll probably keep it at a similar temperature all year long. That should help with consistency.
However, if you keep your house really cold (like below 70 degrees), you might need to find a warm place for the bread to bulk rise, or check out my post on how to make a bread proofer. It also uses things you commonly have around your house, and creates a warmer environment for your bread to rise.
This is what my dough looked like after the 4 sets of stretch and folds. I covered it with plastic wrap and went to bed. Alternately, you can cover it with a damp towel in order to help keep the moisture in the dough.
And this is what it looked like when I woke up in the next morning! So puffy and beautiful and full of air bubbles! This is why you need to make sure you use a large bowl, so there’s room for it to rise!
Shaping Your Overnight Sourdough Bread
When you first wake up the next day, you’ll want to shape your loaves. Put a very very little dusting of flour onto the work surface. Then dump the dough out onto the counter and divide it in half. If the dough sticks to the side of the bowl, you can use a plastic dough scraper to get it all off the sides.
Do not dump it onto a floured surface like you would do with other bread dough. You want it to be a little sticky so that when you’re shaping the loaves, they don’t just slide around on the counter. You want them to stick a little bit and that helps you develop the structure of the bread just a little bit more during that last dough rise time.
*PLEASE NOTE*
DON’T SKIP THIS STEP! THIS RECIPE MAKES 2 ARTISAN LOAVES, SO DIVIDE YOUR DOUGH IN HALF AT THIS POINT. I tend to use a bench knife (also called a bench scraper) for this part, but you can also use the plastic dough scraper.
On each of the two loaves of bread, bring all four sides into the middle. Then flip it upside down onto an area of the counter that has no flour on it. Begin gently pulling it toward yourself. Give it a quarter turn and do it again until it starts to get a nice taught top – usually 4-6 times or so.
I realized I didn’t have any photos for this portion, so I’m linking this video to show you how to do it. The first 2 minutes of the video are great.
I don’t do what she says after that. I do not let it rest and shape it a second time. I’m a lazy sourdough baker and I think that’s overkill!
So I just fold in the edges, flip it, pull it toward myself a few times to get the top nice and taught and then flip the shaped dough upside down into the tea towel lined bowl or banneton for the second rise.
Using a large bowl for overnight sourdough bread
Once it reaches this point, you can line a 2 large bowls with tea towels and generously flour the tea towels. I try to make sure I use a bowl with a more narrow bottom. It makes for a taller loaf that way. Flip the loaves upside down into the bowl so the pretty, smooth side is on the bottom of the bowl. That will be the top of your bread when you bake it!
Using a banneton for overnight sourdough bread
Alternately, you can use a banneton – also called a proofing basket. I’ve used them with the fabric inside and then just covered it with plastic wrap. Some people even just slide it into a plastic bag! I’ve also removed the liner and floured the surface of the banneton and then used the liner to cover it. It gives a really cool circular design to the top of the bread that way.
You absolutely do not need a banneton, but lots of people like to use them!
What kind of flour do I use on the tea towel or banneton?
You can either use regular flour, or you can use rice flour. Regular flour can tend to get a little gummy if it gets too wet. I don’t find that to be a problem with this bread because the hydration of the dough is quite low. I don’t think you need to use one or the other to get the best results. They both turn out well.
However, rice flour is a bit more grainy so it doesn’t clump at all. You can buy rice flour, or throw some white rice in your high powered blender to make a batch. I did love how my first loaf came out when I used it, but I honestly forgot all about it and haven’t used it again!
The Final Rise
Once you shape the 2 loaves, you need to let the dough rest and let it rise a bit more for its final proof. There are two ways you can do the second rise. Either way, you take the bowl with the dough and cover it up with the rest of the tea towel and let it rise.
Bake Immediately
The first thing you can do is to bake it right away. If you do it this way, after you cover the bread, set it on the stove and preheat the oven temperature to 450 degrees with your cast iron dutch oven inside it on the center rack. After at least 1 hour, but as much as 2-3 hours later, you can bake it using the instructions below.
Refrigerate and bake in the next 1-3 days
Another way you can do it – and the way I prefer to do it – is to cover the loaves with the tea towel and pop them into the fridge. Let them sit there for 1-3 days and bake it whenever you’d like in that time period.
When you’re ready to bake, preheat the oven to 450 degrees with the cast iron dutch oven inside it. Once it has been preheating for about an hour, take the dough out of the fridge and follow the baking instructions below.
When you refrigerate the dough, it allows for a longer fermentation period. Additionally, it is much easier to score when it’s cold! So if you want to practice pretty scoring, this really helps. Also, when you do it this way, you can take one loaf out to bake and leave the rest of the dough in the fridge to bake fresh the next day!
Baking your Overnight Sourdough Bread
When you’re ready to bake the sourdough, preheat the oven to 450 degrees. Put the cast iron dutch oven into the oven while it’s preheating. Allow it to heat for about an hour before you bake your bread. You want a really hot dutch oven to bake the bread in because it gives it a better oven spring and makes it nice and fluffy.
Rip a piece of parchment paper a little larger than your loaf of bread. This is the brand I use. Dump the loaf of sourdough out onto the parchment paper so that the seam side is down and the smooth side it up. The part that was in the bottom of the bowl is now the top of the loaf.
Score it
Use a very sharp knife or a lame or a straight razor blade to score the top of the dough. You can just make a slash in the bread like I did below. Or you can practice making fancy designs in it. It tastes the same either way!
Once it’s slashed, lift the piece of parchment paper and gently set the dough and parchment inside the dutch oven. Put the lid on quickly and let it cook for 20 minutes.
After the 20 minutes is up, take off the lid and cook for another 10-15 minutes. I usually cook for 10 to get a golden brown, but my brother in law loves the color to be deeper and lets his go longer. There’s no right way to do it. Just let it cook until it is the color you like to see.
Take it out of the oven and set it on a cooling rack or a wire rack. Resist the urge to cut it until it’s cooled. If you cut it while it’s still hot, it can make the inside of the loaf gummy. People don’t realized that all that steam trapped inside keeps cooking the dough for a while.
I cook mine one loaf at a time in the dutch oven so I just cook them back to back and it works well for me. Some people say to let the oven and cast iron dutch oven reheat before you make the second loaf. I don’t find that I need to do that.
Do I have to do Stretch and Folds?
If you have a Kitchenaid, it can do the stretching and folding for you by kneading your dough with a dough hook! This is the simplest way to make overnight sourdough bread in my opinion.
Making overnight sourdough bread without stretch and folds
Put all the ingredients into the Kitchenaid stand mixer, fitted with the dough hook attachment. Turn it on low. As soon as the dough comes together, set a timer for 5 min and let it knead your dough.
Overnight rise
After the 5 minutes, cover the dough with plastic wrap or a damp towel and allow it to rise overnight.
Shaping into loaves
In the morning, shape the dough into loaves. At this point, you can throw it into the fridge for 1-3 days, or you can let it rise for about 1-2 hours. Preheat the oven and cast iron dutch oven for an hour and bake the bread following the instructions above.
Here’s a photo I took this morning of the bread I made using this method. See? Perfectly fluffy and golden and beautiful and no stretch and folds!
(As a side note, the loaf below had a 2nd rise in a banneton with no liner. That’s what made the spiral design on top!)
Can I use whole grains?
Yes! I’ve made this with whole wheat flour, spelt, emmer, and rye. It’s important to know that you don’t want to exceed 30% of the overall flour weight in whole grains if you want it to stay light and fluffy. So you’ll use a mixture of flour consisting of about 300g of whole grains and 750g of bread flour. That gives you the nutty whole grain flavor and the light fluffy consistency in your homemade bread.
Can I use sourdough discard for this overnight sourdough bread recipe?
You sure can! While using an active and bubbly starter will yield the fluffiest results, I’ve often used sourdough discard in my bread and still had wonderful results. Sometimes it needs to sit a little longer in order to get the full rise, but I’ve had other times where it rose just as quickly! You do, however, need to make sure it’s a starter you’ve fed and used in the last week or so. I you use really old sourdough starter from your fridge, it may give you flat loaves. It is always best and yields the most consistent results if you use freshly fed starter that is active and bubbly.
So these are my best tips for simple overnight sourdough bread! I’d love to hear how the process goes for you. I hope you find this overnight method to be an easy sourdough bread recipe that you can fall in love with. Let me know in the comments!
Basic Overnight Sourdough Bread
Once you get the hang of it, making overnight sourdough bread is a simple thing to add into your schedule…and it tastes delicious!
Ingredients
- 180 grams Sourdough Starter
- 660 grams Filtered Water
- 1050 grams Bread Flour
- 20 grams Salt
Instructions
1. Feed Your Sourdough Starter
Begin by feeding your sourdough starter. I normally do this at lunchtime so it's ready to use in the early evening because I mix up my dough 2 hours before bedtime.
Place 100g. sourdough starter in a jar with 100g. filtered water and 100g. unbleached flour. Mix well and allow to sit loosely covered for 6-8 hours, until it is doubled in size.
2. Mix Ingredients
About 2 hours before bed, mix all the ingredients (flour, water, starter, and salt) in a bowl with a wooden spoon.
Oftentimes you won't be able to incorporate all the flour into the dough, so use your hands to work the flour in.
3. Stretch and Folds
Cover the dough and allow it to rise for 30 min. Then uncover it and do a series of "stretch and folds" by grabbing the dough, stretching it up and folding it over. Turn the dough 1/4 turn and repeat. Do this 4-8 times until the dough is too tight to stretch. Cover the dough with plastic wrap.
Repeat this process every 30 minutes for 2 hours, or a total of 4 times.
4. 1st Rise
After the final stretch and fold, cover the dough with plastic wrap and allow to rise overnight.
5. Shape Loaves
When you first wake up, you'll want to shape your loaves. Dump the dough out onto the counter.
*THIS RECIPE MAKES 2 LOAVES SO DIVIDE IT IN HALF AT THIS POINT*
On one half of the dough, bring all four sides into the middle. Then flip it upside down and begin gently pulling it toward yourself. Give it a quarter turn and do it again until it starts to get a nice taught top.
Once it reaches this point, you can line a mixing bowl with a tea bowl and generously flour the tea towel. I try to make sure I use a tea towel with a more narrow bottom. It makes for a taller loaf that way. Flip the loaf upside down into the bowl so the pretty, taught top is on the bottom of the bowl. That will be the top of your bread when you bake it!
Alternately, you can use a banneton. I've used them with the fabric inside and then just covered it with plastic wrap. I've also removed the liner and floured the surface of the banneton and then used the liner to cover it. It gives a really cool circular design to the top of the bread that way.
You absolutely do not need a banneton, but lots of people like to use them!
REPEAT THIS PROCESS WITH THE SECOND LOAF.
6. 2nd Rise
There are two ways you can do the second rise. Either way, you take the bowl with the dough and cover it up with the rest of the tea towel and let it rise.
7. Bake
Rip a piece of parchment paper a little larger than your loaf of bread. This is the brand I use. Dump the loaf of sourdough out onto the parchment paper. The part that was in the bottom of the bowl is now the top of the loaf.
Use a very sharp knife or a lame to score the dough. You can just make a slash in the bread or you can practice making fancy designs in it. It tastes the same either way!
Once it's slashed, lift the parchment paper and gently set the dough and parchment inside the dutch oven. Put the lid on quickly and let it cook for 20 minutes.
After the 20 minutes is up, take off the lid and cook for another 10-15 minutes. I usually cook for 10 but my brother in law loves the color to be deeper and lets his go longer. There's no right way to do it. Just let it cook until it is the color you like to see.
Take it out of the oven and set it on a cooling rack. Resist the urge to cut it until it's cooled. If you cut it while it's still hot, it can make the inside of the loaf gummy. People don't realized that all that steam trapped inside keeps cooking the dough for a while.
Option 1 - Bake Immediately
The first thing you can do is to bake it right away. If you do it this way, after you cover the bread, set it on the stove and preheat the oven to 450 degrees with your cast iron dutch oven inside it. After at least 1 hour, but as much as 2-3 hours later, you can bake it using the instructions below.
Option 2 - Refrigerate and bake in the next 1-3 days
Another way you can do it – and the way I prefer to do it – is to cover the loaf with the tea towel and pop it into the fridge. Let it sit there for 1-3 days and bake it whenever you'd like in that time period.
When you're ready to bake, preheat the oven to 450 degrees with the cast iron dutch oven inside it. Once it has been preheating for about an hour, take the dough out of the fridge and follow the baking instructions below.
When you're ready to bake the sourdough, preheat the oven to 450 degrees. Put the cast iron dutch oven into the oven while it's preheating. Allow it to heat for about an hour before you bake your bread.
Notes
If you'd like to add whole grains to your loaf, I recommend starting at about 30% of the overall weight of flour being whole grain. Ex. use 300g of whole wheat flour and 750g of bread flour. This keeps it nice and fluffy!
Pin for Later!
This turned out beautiful! I’m going to have to try this one!
Thank you!!
I can’t wait to try this recipe! Looks delicious.
I hope you love it!!
What a gorgeous sourdough bread! I absolutely love artisan sourdough…
Thank you!!
I love seeing all the ways people are perfecting sourdough bread. I can’t stand anything else anymore. We’ll have to put this beside overnight oats and be all set for the day!
Don’t you love overnight stuff? It makes the next day so much easier!
I had some sourdough rising in the oven with it off. I forgot it was in there and preheated the oven to 450 to bake a pizza. The saran wrap over the bowl melted. What can I do with the dough. It has started to brown on top.
Oh man. I’m so sorry. I’ve done that too! I’d just cut the top off so it doesn’t have any Saran Wrap on it and bake it off and see what happens! Good luck!
Is the recipe for 1 or 2 loaves? There’s a reference midway through the dividing the dough, but everything else is singular. I’m not sure if I’m going to end up with one huge loaf or if I need to take some out!
Oh! I can see how this can be confusing! It is for two loaves. I will make sure to go back and switch the language so it’s less vague!
Many ways to make bread. Speed of baking sometimes trumps taste. This recipe is an excellent compromise between the two.
Awww thank you!
You state you feed your starter using 100g each starter, water and flour. I generally get my starter from the frig the night before (if making bread next morning or the morning of if making bread later in the day) and feed it but not with the amounts you use. Are these amounts necessary for your recipe
Also can you provide instructions for baking in a loaf pan. I cover my loaf pan with a second loaf pan and bake about the same times as you instructed above.
Thanks for the questions! Yes, you can use your starter even if it has differing weights than what I mentioned. While I always used to measure my feeding to make sure it was all even like in this post, now I know what it should look like, so I just do it by sight.
When I use loaf pans, I do exactly what you said! I cover with another pan and let it cook for 20 min and then uncover it for 10-15 minutes.
Are you able to freeze the dough for later baking?
Yes! You would need to defrost it and then allow it to get to room temperature before you throw it in the oven. I often freeze it after baking it and it works perfectly. Let me know how it goes for you if you try freezing it!
Followed the recipe exactly and my loaves didn’t rise in the oven and turned out flat. Do you know what I could change next time?
I’m so sorry about that! How long did you let it rise the first time? And the second rise, did you do in the fridge or on the counter? Also, you cooked it in a dutch oven? And was the dutch oven preheated in the oven? Sometimes if it is overrisen, it will deflate. Or if it isn’t risen enough, it won’t get that oven spring. But if you did both rises and then had it in a covered and preheated dutch oven, that should provide the steam it needs to get that rise in the oven.
What size Dutch oven do you use? I had same issue in the past and wondered if my Dutch oven was too large?
My dutch oven is quite large. Not sure what the measurements are though.
Thanks for your great recipes! If you elect to do second proof in refrigerator, do you need to bring to room temp before baking, or does it go straight into oven from fridge? If I’m reading correctly, it goes straight into oven, but I just wanted to make sure!
Yes! Good question! It does go directly into the oven cold. It makes it so easy!
Hi!! For the first rise it goes on the counter? Not the fridge?
Right! You can do it in the fridge too if you’d like but it will just take longer when doing a cool rise.
After I shaped my door and let it rise for the second time, when I went to take it out, it was super mushy and didn’t hold its shape and a bit sticky still. I kind of just threw it into the Dutch oven. What did I do wrong?
Maybe it was over risen. I’ve over risen mine a couple times and it won’t stay in shape and just keeps going flat. I’m so sorry you had that issue 🙁
I see this makes 2 loaves. Do you cook them at the same time? I’m assuming yes if you are doing them in loaf pans..but what about if doing in dutch ovens? Do you cook one at a time? the half you are not cooking can it just sit out on counter while other is cooking?
I do cook them one at a time if I’m using the dutch oven. If I’m rising them on the counter, I just keep the second one on the counter while the first one cooks. If I had the second rise in the refrigerator, then I can even bake them on different days! Sometimes I fit two dutch ovens in at the same time and just cook one in each, but then I can do it at the same time.
I’m new and just wondering – this recipe is specifically for 2 loaves? What if I only wanted to make one? I enjoy your instructions, but just wondering why you have to divide the dough in half.
Good question! You could half the recipe and only make a single loaf. Or, what I do often is to make the full recipe and then wrap the second loaf in Saran Wrap and then a ziplock bag and freeze it once it’s cooled. It defrosts and tastes perfect!
Can I use all purpose flour instead of bread flour?
Absolutely! Bread flour has more gluten in it, so it usually works a little better for things that require a rise. But I’ve used all purpose and it will work well!
How long does it take the dough to rise the second time? And do i have to do the second rise in the fridge?
It depends on the temperature of your house, but I usually do the second rise for about 2 hours if it’s at room temperature. I put it on the stove top while the oven is preheating. If you do the second rise in the fridge, it can be in there from overnight to 3 days. You can do either!
We all love this recipe and my 6 year old gives it a 10/10 “so good Momma!”
We played around with it and even put poppy seeds, toasted coconut, raisins and dried cranberries. Yummy for breakfast and lunches.
That sounds DELICIOUS!! Thanks for the idea! I’m so glad you enjoyed it!
I would also like to add that I really appreciate the instructions for using the stand mixer for the 5min instead of stretch and pulls!! Such a time saver. Thank you!
I love that sourdough is so flexible and not as complicated as people make it out to be!
The stand mixer instructions is what got me to try this recipe after sifting through all kinds of sourdough recipes!
I’m so glad to know that! I do really love to do the stretch and folds, but it’s so nice when you have the option to have the KitchenAid do it for you!
WOW mine came out amazing!! Thanks for a simple recipe!!
This made my day! Thank you SO much for coming back to tell me that!!!!!
I love this bread! This is my fourth time making it, second time this week. My all night rise this time didn’t go as well. All done the same way. It’s been 12 hours and not rising much and not sure what to do. Separate, form and try the 2nd rise? HELP
I’m so glad it has worked for you so well until now!! Was your house cooler this time around? Even a few degrees can make a big difference. I’d make them into loaves and do a second rise in a nice warm place and see if that helps. Check out my post on making a proofing box. You can usually do it with things you have around the house and it makes a nice warm and toasty environment for the bread to rise. You may need to 2nd rise longer than the 2 hours or so that it normally takes. You may also want to throw a couple ice cubes in the dutch oven when you bake it to try to even give it some more oven spring to help the rise. Additionally, I’ve been opening the dutch oven up at the 5 minute mark and recutting the score. Then I cover it back up and let it finish out the remainder of the 20 minutes covered. I feel like this helps it get as much rise as possible in the oven. Good luck!!! I find that almost all my loaves are edible, even if they are not quite as light and fluffy as I like! Please let me know how it turns out!
These were the easiest instructions to follow thank you. It was not a lot of work and it works with my SAHM schedule since most of the work is done at night which I do when my kids are in bed. The bread baked deliciously it was a little chewy so I’m adjusting the temperature and water to troubleshoot
Thank you for the feedback!!!! It’s amazing how little “hands on” time there is! You might want to try to bake it with the lid on for maybe 15 and then do lid off for 15. I wonder if that would make it less chewy since it’s exposed to the air for more time? I do think sourdough has a traditionally chewier exterior. But when I make them in loaf pans with another pan on top, it makes the crust thinner. So that might help?
This has been my go to recipe! It has never failed me. I love to be able to make 2 loaves as well. I was wondering, could I make the loaves smaller and have 3 or 4 smaller loaves instead of 2 big loaves? I’ve been thinking about trying to do so. What would your advice be on changing the bake time?
I’m so glad it’s working well for you!!! I use this recipe to make 3 loaf pans and it’s perfect. I use the same timing. I think you could also make 4 cute little artisan loaves. I’d still top 20 min with the lid on and then just watch the first time you do it to see if it needs the full 10 min afterwards to brown up! Let me know what you do!
It worked!! I ended up cooking 20 mins lid on, and 10 off. They are the most perfect little loaves! 🫶🏻
Yay!!!!! I love it!!